I don't think anyone has bashed buying an OEM part. Yes, some people have said something about a group buy, it's not really what this thread is about.
So we're wrong because we want to make something?
I at no point said the original design was flawed. I also said that I am probably going to order an OEM part to use as a template and use on my car through Champion. As a matter of fact, I'll probably be ordering it tonight. Yes, Champion is a great deal, I know, I've ordered parts from them and I am happy, WE GET THE POINT. Or I do anyway.
No one is pointing a gun at anyone's head and saying you have to use a cover someone here designs. Yeah, I realize that the airflow won't be the same if we make some changes. That's the designer's prerogative. I'd rather have a little bit more durability and have something there than have another stock one tear off and drag and NOT be there.
You never know. Somebody might hit on something that is convenient for various reason, durable, and cost-effective. Maybe not. However, having worked in engineering both in school and at work, I can appreciate the following idea:
Yes, toyota had millions of dollars in funding for R&D when they made the car (and hence the cover). Yes, the engineers are intelligent people. But it all boils down to the fact that no engineer, regardless of education, training, and experience, is infallible. Design decisions are made only partly on the performance of the design, and I find it hard to believe that anyone here believes OEM designs are always the best. If that was the case, NONE of you would have any mods whatsoever, unless you were retarded. My Bronco, for example. I love it to death. It rarely breaks. But when it does, dear god in Heaven, it turns into a bitch. Poor OEM design decisions from a practicality standpoint in that truck.
And figgie, I'll put it this way- Almost anything is possible from a design standpoint, you just have to work at it. Quit being so negative. If a design isn't so good, you work to improve it. When it comes to almost any part in the world, it is not black and white, or "OEM designed or don't bother."