drilled vs slotted rotors.. or neither

Insidious Surmiser

Formerly 89jdm7m
May 12, 2006
2,172
0
0
Oceanfront
MK3Brent said:
You have drilled rotors already. What made you decide on them?
i got a good deal IMO 250$ for 4 brembo rotors and axxis ceramic pads

and another note to all that commented on the rotors. I'm still looking for facts here :-/... I just keep hearing "IMO", but i'm trying to form an oppinion from proven facts, rather than other oppinions. :dunno:
 

suprageezer

New Member
Aug 27, 2005
778
0
0
Southern California
Wanna know what works BEST? take a look at any High Performance car sold today. They have the same issues as we do, stopping power, and anti fade, reliabilty, wear rates, liablity etc. go to a porsche dealer, maybe a ferrari dealer, cause what they run has got to be the best available not just some crap some friend of a friend who said his neighbor had this or that rotors and they did this or that. It's all pretty much common knowledge in the high performance world that makes cars today in 2006.
 

Insidious Surmiser

Formerly 89jdm7m
May 12, 2006
2,172
0
0
Oceanfront
well, the reason i stated this thread is because i've heard this and that, such as

-slotted rotors wear on the brakes faster, and doesn't really serve a purpose, as moder pads don't create gas

- brakes w/ no holes or slots provide a greater surface area for the pad to make contact

stuff of that sort, but there was no factual information behind these statements
 

Big Wang Bandit

You Can't Quit Me Baby
Feb 21, 2006
7,551
0
0
35
San Ramon, CA - 925!
Ill have a picture for you soon. A picture is worth 1000 words.

Facts, Go to a Mercedes/Porsche/Ferrari deaership(as stated). They do work better.

Brake cooling is VERY VERY important. Ill try to dig up some information for you on both inquiries.
 

Insidious Surmiser

Formerly 89jdm7m
May 12, 2006
2,172
0
0
Oceanfront
HellsLegion said:
Ill have a picture for you soon. A picture is worth 1000 words.

Facts, Go to a Mercedes/Porsche/Ferrari deaership(as stated). They do work better.

Brake cooling is VERY VERY important. Ill try to dig up some information for you on both inquiries.
thanks, simply put, like i said, i couldn't really ever find any good info, so i couldn't figure out if it was just a gimmick or actually an improvement
 

shaeff

Kurt is FTMFW x2!!!!
Staff member
Super Moderator
Mar 30, 2005
10,589
10
38
Around
as stated several times, slotted is good, drilled is good if they're CAST that way. drilling holes in rotors is bad...

-shaeff
 

starscream5000

Senior VIP Member
Aug 23, 2006
6,359
0
36
Hot and Humid, KY
born2drv said:
some people don't like it, some say they crack, etc, etc... i have some ebay rotors (drilled and slotted) and ult pads and they stop great for me. they guy had all positive feedback, so i figured why not since my brakes were very bad and I just wanted something to get me by for now. I'm sure a big brake kit would be a million times better but for what i paid i'm very satisified.

this is what i bought:
iRotors Cross-Drilled & Slotted F/R Rotors
PBR ULT Ceramic F/R Brake Pads

Installed January 15, 2006. So far so good.

Hey! I bought a full brake kit from these guys also, but they're for my 3G. I got the drilled/slotted rotors, axxis metal master brake pads, and SS brake lines all the way around for 400 even.

Funny thing is, I bought my supra RIGHT after i paid for these. I have them here sitting under my comp desk EVERYTHING IS UNOPENED! If you guys know someone who has a 3G GT or GTS I'll sell these to them for 300 bucks!

BTW: The box they are in is fucking heavy!
 

Yellow 13

Lurker
Apr 4, 2006
2,308
0
36
Fairfield, California
Heres what the Porsche Lemans car uses:

GT2brakes.jpg



Most rally cars I see use the same setup.

If thats what cars of those calibers are using I assume its a good thing.
 

iwannadie

New Member
Jul 28, 2006
981
0
0
gilbert, az
most drilled rotors are for weight issues as well i thought. saving a few pounds on an other wise stock supra isnt worth it, to me.

also, of course theres no end all answer to what brakes are better. other wise wed all be running the same setupha.
 

wingman

sucka got blammed!
Sep 11, 2005
427
0
0
35
Phoenix, AZ
stoptech made a fairly large writeup on the topic, weighing both the pros and cons of each setup and which one is better for the desired application.

going by that, it's slotted all the way for me.
 

figgie

Supramania Contributor
Mar 30, 2005
5,225
16
38
50
Twin Cities, Minnesot-ah
born2drv said:
some of high end oem manufacturers and race teams use slottled, drilled or both. they wouldn't use it if it wasn't proven effective, especially the automakers since they like to cut costs as much as possible. just my 2c.

[cracks knuckles]

nope

that is not the reason they use them ;)

They use cross drilling to save WEIGHT not to improve braking. Back in the 60's/70's the pads gassed out like hell. Now a days that is not an issue even in a race circuit. Also remember that RACE teams chuck the rotors after each and every race. Slotting was used to help with the gassing out the pads. Again now a days it is not needed. And anyway if you compare the crossdrilling density of a true race setup vs the looky loo crap that the street setups get it is not even close.

HellsLegion said:
Oh no, BTD, They are proven and work wonders. They just need to be made correctly! Not just some bum with a drillpress. Im trying to get a pic of an MR2 buddy who cracked his.

Proven to work in reducing weight and that is about it. Trade off. Lose weight lose longevity.

so the real answer is, unless you are willing to replace the rotors OFTEN then neither option is a good option. Brakes are an energy tank. It stores heat and disipates it. If it can not store heat that when you start getting warped rotors. Crossdrilling/slotting takes away MASS which in the brake system made of steel or iron you need to store heat!

suprageezer said:
Wanna know what works BEST? take a look at any High Performance car sold today. They have the same issues as we do, stopping power, and anti fade, reliabilty, wear rates, liablity etc. go to a porsche dealer, maybe a ferrari dealer, cause what they run has got to be the best available not just some crap some friend of a friend who said his neighbor had this or that rotors and they did this or that. It's all pretty much common knowledge in the high performance world that makes cars today in 2006.


ahh more interwebbar myths!

FYI Racing porche and Ferraris do not run now where near the same components as the racing cousins. Ceramic based brakes disk vs CF/CF or densely crossdrilled STEEL rotors (notice I did not say Iron like the street brethrens, rotational mass removal is king in racing).


HellsLegion said:
Ill have a picture for you soon. A picture is worth 1000 words.



Facts, Go to a Mercedes/Porsche/Ferrari deaership(as stated). They do work better.



Brake cooling is VERY VERY important. Ill try to dig up some information for you on both inquiries.


lol se my above statements ;)
 

Clip

The Magnificent Seven
Oct 16, 2005
2,738
9
38
35
Virginia
figgie, i've heard myths that powerslot rotors warp. any input on this?

i myself am running drilled/slotted brembos from driftmotion, anyone know if these were drilled or cast?

everything seems fine right now, i've had them on for about 8 months and they work great with the porterfield pads and lines.
 

Clip

The Magnificent Seven
Oct 16, 2005
2,738
9
38
35
Virginia
good god, only with a fair amount of machining and custom work. if IJ were around he could fill you in on all that.
 

JustAnotherVictim

Supramania Contributor
Clip said:
figgie, i've heard myths that powerslot rotors warp. any input on this?

i myself am running drilled/slotted brembos from driftmotion, anyone know if these were drilled or cast?

everything seems fine right now, i've had them on for about 8 months and they work great with the porterfield pads and lines.
I actually read that actual brake rotor warp is pretty much a myth and a misused term for a separate problem.
I'd have to find that article though.