Thanks for the info Cj! Maybe now I can figure out which one is which. There definately is a difference in the beams, the left one is a fair bit brighter than the right. Here's some night shots for comparison:
First photo: Stock low beams on my Mk2 (same bulbs as a stock Mk3):
Stock hi beams on my Mk2:
HID conversion with 6000K color 9006 bulb in the camaro bulb housings(low beams)
Piaa 1100 driving lights by themselves (used as hi-beams)
Both the HID's and Piaa's together:
Street shots- HID lows:
Not quite as blue as this photo:
This photo is closest to the real color. Crystal white with a very faint hint of blue.
HID's with Piaa hi beams on also: Looks good in the photo but the hi beams are not as good as the stock ones were.
Once both lenses are as bright as the left one is, it'll be awesome!