personally?? I'd get that 86.5 becasue it's a rare color combo (looks AWESOME in person, especially with bronze wheels) and the miles aren't too high for the year...
depends on if it really is as good as the pics say though.
just strt looking, I've seen cars look GREAT in ads and look like utter garbage in person, or the other way around. get pics and post em here and we can usually tell you what it's worth...
don't forget to carfax!
