Meh...what's 1 or 2 teeth

Max travel on the CPS...low vac...running like crap = jumped timing.
Assuming the rest of the tensioner is good, all you need is the spring (a new one). Remember what I told you about torque on that. After 500 miles or so after replacement, you *should always* check timing belt tension and do a reset on the tensioner. I suspect you didn't Kenny, and this is often the result.
Once you get it all lined up, it would still be a good idea to do the dowel trick and confirm the #1 piston is in fact at TDC with the crank pointing at zero.