limequat said:4. If the light turned yellow as the Bimmer was turning, your light would still be red. Even if it had just turned red as he was going through, your light would be red or just turned green. You'd have to accelerate to your claimed speed of 35 mph to hit him. Or, you maintained your claimed 35 MPH approaching a red light, then it turned just as you got to the intersection.
Im pretty sure the beemer was in the middle of the intersection waiting to turn and he saw yellow and went. His view was probably blocked by another car also in the middle of the intersection waiting to turn the other way. Although he did go thru a yellow light (completely legal, as yellow light means stop if you can) it is illegal to wait in the intersection to turn. Most cops wont give you a ticket for it but it is illegal. But this would explain the dent on his passenger side fender.