malloy's rods did Not break because of power, they broke because of other issues, duane ran 650+ on stock rods and his motor did not break because of power either.... i have spoke with numerous machine shops and NONE of them recomend eagles, the same reasons as forementioned, which is why i went with stock- shot peened. i had them recondishioned and shot peened for about 250$ my motor has seen 500+ rwhp for over a year now and about 50 passes down the 1/4 mile, with NO problems whatsoever.
please get your facts strait..... 99 times out of 100 it is not the rod's fault, it is either the Tuner/Driver of the car, the rod bolts(fix that with arp), or the machine shop/engine builder not noticing a small deadly flaw in the rod BEFORE assembling the engine.
Also you DO NOT want NEW stock rods... old used ones are better, the heat cycling over time makes them naturally stronger, again it is all about checking the specs and making sure they are good before assembling the bottom end.
just ask yourself why eagles are 500$ when all the other aftermarket rods are 1200$..... it is already known that the mk3 crowd (including me sometimes) loves to cheap out and buy what LOOKS good and saves $$$.....
in conclusion, i have compared side to side eagles and stock, and was not impressed. if you have money buy a 1200$ set of rods, if not stick with stock.