There are several explanations for the perceived loss of preload he observed and there's nothing that says his gasket would have failed if he'd done nothing. I realize it flies in the face of common wisdom here (which is why I rarely get involved) but retorque also flies in the face of long established engineering principles regarding clamped joints (including gasketed ones) and fasteners. If the initial torquing of the joint/fastener was done correctly (a big if) there's no need for it. Talk to any competent ME. Your car though. If it makes you feel better go for it...