He's right^^^, but why would the #6 cylinder be full of coolant, and #1 be dry? I would think you would see the coolant up at the front of the motor, where the gap was...
I think that since you already have the head off, just clean the block and head up really well, check them both for flatness, and make sure the lower timing cover is flush with the deck surface. And because you have milkshake for oil, doesn't that mean that the internals (rod bearings) are already damaged? You may want to consider a full rebuild, and do a MHG... If not, you will have to flush the head block, and every oil line thoroughly, and get a Toyota OEM head gasket from the dealer if you decide to go composite, just to see if the Head gasket really was the problem.
Your problem is really weird, if the head gasket was as bad as you are saying...smoking, and the obvious milkshake, I would think that your compression numbers would be way off. Your numbers are pretty much normal.
edit: What kind of head fasteners did you use? And what were they torqued to?