60-1 reliability issues?

TheNewRed

New Member
Oct 19, 2007
572
0
0
36
WA
So i've been thinking of keeping the CT and going 57 trim or 60-1, but i constantly here about the reliability of the 60-1, or should i say lack there of. I have heard that the shaft snaps under pretty high loads, are there any other issues with going to 60-1. So im thinking if i do go to 60-1, im going to have all of the rotating assembly cryo treated by these guys http://deepfreezecryo.com/home.htm I would think that doing that it could solve the shaft snapping problem.... What do you guys think???
 

wardog

R.G.V WARDOG
Jan 19, 2006
564
0
16
ALTON, TX
Im no turbo expert but from the discusions that i have read about the ct26/60-1, 80% of the people are gonna tell u to go with the 57 trim. I personally have a ct26/60-1 on my car and made 350rwhp on 11psi . I had it rebuilt by majestic turbos of waco, tx 11 months ago and no signs of shaft play so far. If u want something that is not as big as the 60-1 or small as the 57trim a 60 trim falls righ in between them two but it is all up to you . There is a dyno of a 57 trim making aroung 420 rwhp with race gas and there is Jbl that made 455rwhp and 490ft/lbs or torque with a 60 trim ct and stock 440s. The cryo treatment should make the shaft stronger just like it does pistons and every other part that is cryo treated...
 

IwantMKIII

WVU MAEngineering
Jun 12, 2007
2,477
0
0
Perkasie, PA
wardog;923635 said:
Im no turbo expert but from the discusions that i have read about the ct26/60-1, 80% of the people are gonna tell u to go with the 57 trim. I personally have a ct26/60-1 on my car and made 350rwhp on 11psi . I had it rebuilt by majestic turbos of waco, tx 11 months ago and no signs of shaft play so far. If u want something that is not as big as the 60-1 or small as the 57trim a 60 trim falls righ in between them two but it is all up to you . There is a dyno of a 57 trim making aroung 420 rwhp with race gas and there is Jbl that made 455rwhp and 490ft/lbs or torque with a 60 trim ct and stock 440s. The cryo treatment should make the shaft stronger just like it does pistons and every other part that is cryo treated...


lol i can make 330+ on a tune and my stock CT at 12PSI.....wish i didn't develop rod knock as of today though to prove it :cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry::cry:


BTW, stick with 57GT trim.....hands down....
 

TheNewRed

New Member
Oct 19, 2007
572
0
0
36
WA
But no one is saying anything about the cryo treating, or if the shaft is the ONLY problem????
 

starscream5000

Senior VIP Member
Aug 23, 2006
6,359
0
36
Hot and Humid, KY
wardog;923635 said:
Im no turbo expert but from the discusions that i have read about the ct26/60-1, 80% of the people are gonna tell u to go with the 57 trim. I personally have a ct26/60-1 on my car and made 350rwhp on 11psi . I had it rebuilt by majestic turbos of waco, tx 11 months ago and no signs of shaft play so far. If u want something that is not as big as the 60-1 or small as the 57trim a 60 trim falls righ in between them two but it is all up to you . There is a dyno of a 57 trim making aroung 420 rwhp with race gas and there is Jbl that made 455rwhp and 490ft/lbs or torque with a 60 trim ct and stock 440s. The cryo treatment should make the shaft stronger just like it does pistons and every other part that is cryo treated...

Are you still running it at 11 psi?

I think a lot of the snapped CT's stem from running higher boost on a heavier wheel...
 

Cya

New Member
Aug 12, 2005
628
0
0
41
Columbia, S.C>
From reading about other's experience with the ct upgades the 57 trim was the best all around turbo. Meaning good torque curve and good hp with the best relibility while the 60-1 had more power overall but the power didnt outweigh the the reliability. When I say more power I say about 20-30hp while the 57 took nitrous and ran more 11's and lasted.

You also want to talk about clipping when upgrading, id say 10-12 degrees they have shown the best results without that much more lag.
 

Cya

New Member
Aug 12, 2005
628
0
0
41
Columbia, S.C>
the shaft is the weak point, its too small for bigger wheels (60+mm). i have heard of cryo treating helping for longevity, but 2000 miles is less than one oil change i dont think that would help that much. my next question would be about the turbine housing and the small wastegate hole during shifts. I think an MR2 housing would do wonders for an upgraded ct since its has two holes for excess exhaust outlet oppossed to the one. Does this make since? if not let me know.
 

TheNewRed

New Member
Oct 19, 2007
572
0
0
36
WA
Im still not getting a staight awnser, will cryo treating the shaft help, and how much.... And how long do the 60-1s usually last at say 15-18 psi???
 

MDCmotorsports

Offical SM Expert: Turbochargers
SM Expert
Mar 31, 2005
4,194
2
38
43
Indy 500
www.MDCmotorsports.com
You're not going to get one because most of the people who have responded in this thread have NFI or clue about what they are talking about.

thebullshitbrigade said:
"Ct shafts are weak and snap from 60-1 compressor wheels....
STOP THIS HEARSAY BULLSHIT RIGHT NOW, IT WON'T BE TOLERATED

Im serious people. Stop the rumor mill(s). If you don't know, don't say it or post it.

The ct26 shaft (nose) is larger than the to4E / to4b shaft that the 60-1 came on straight from Garrett.

Stop spreading bullshit facts that you dont' know about.

What kills a ct26 60-1 is two things:

1.) Unbalanced assembly. This is because most balancing systems are a heinz based system. Trying to balance a ct26 turbine with this compressor wheel is a real shot in the dark as Heinz doesn't give you calibration codes for such a combination.

2.) The 60-1 wheel flows more air than the stock ct26 housing was designed for. This leads to compressor surge. Compressor surge = death.

Now stop posting ignorance!

Oh, and the TheNewRed, don't even think about cryotreating that shaft unless you want it to do some funky stuff....
 

TheNewRed

New Member
Oct 19, 2007
572
0
0
36
WA
Thank you sir(MDC Motorsports), at what point does it start to surge, i dont plan on going over 18psi, whats that sound like? O and why would it do "funny stuff" after the cryo treatment?
 

MDCmotorsports

Offical SM Expert: Turbochargers
SM Expert
Mar 31, 2005
4,194
2
38
43
Indy 500
www.MDCmotorsports.com
No need to call me sir lol.

Youtube compressor surge and you'll understand.

I don't know of any one out there that has hard data as to when the 60-1 actually starts to surge or under what conditions it does surge.

The fact is - it does. ;-)

Those shafts are inconel and high carbon steel.

It was designed to rotate at over 100,000 rpm and withstand super heated gasses.

You don't want to mess with those mollecules (sp?)....
 

GrimJack

Administrator
Dec 31, 1969
12,377
3
38
56
Richmond, BC, Canada
idriders.com
There is a reason people have NFI about fixing a 60-1. Virtually nobody bothers to fix it when they break, they just move on to a different turbo. When my 60-1 got death whine before my first oil change, I took it off, put it on the shelf, and bought a new Turbonetics unit.

I still have the 60-1, one day I might send it in to figure out what went wrong.
 

TheNewRed

New Member
Oct 19, 2007
572
0
0
36
WA
MDCmotorsports;924285 said:
No need to call me sir lol.

Youtube compressor surge and you'll understand.



You don't want to mess with those mollecules (sp?)....
I know what compressor surge is i just wanted to no if there was a solid border as to when it began..... Thanks though ian i feel you on the mollecular structure of the shaft.
 

danysbanshee

New Member
Jan 18, 2008
36
0
0
maine
As far as the cryo treating, it can't hurt. Theres a company in Nh a few hrs away from me that sells chainsaws. They treat the whole saw. Then guarentee it forever. Guarentee a chansaw that runs at 13000 rmps constantly. It must work.
 

MDCmotorsports

Offical SM Expert: Turbochargers
SM Expert
Mar 31, 2005
4,194
2
38
43
Indy 500
www.MDCmotorsports.com
danysbanshee;924679 said:
As far as the cryo treating, it can't hurt. Theres a company in Nh a few hrs away from me that sells chainsaws. They treat the whole saw. Then guarentee it forever. Guarentee a chansaw that runs at 13000 rmps constantly. It must work.


Go away NEWB. Please.