You are only looking at half the theory. The reason the turbo is making boost earlier and load is greater at that point is because it is now harder for the engine to move the car. It's a trade off and the rear should be matched to what the car is and what the car is doing, it should not be generalized for all MKIIIs.
You can argue theory all you want, but theory is just a theory. There's no substitute for hands on experience. Run a 3.73 vs a 4.30 in a 450whp, 26" tire car in the 1/4 and the better matched rear will make itself very clear. The 3.73 wont even get halfway through 4th when passing the traps. In an 800whp car, you'll want that 3.73 because then it'll be more closely matched to run through the traps at a decent RPM.
Choosing a rear is not voodoo and there is no opinion involved when you disregard streetability. Given a certain tire size, powerband, weight and redline, there is a difinitive faster rear than other rear choices.