I've owned and loved both myself. Both cars can be fun depending on your past. If you are used to driving a beater, an MKII is a fun car to drive. I used to love how I could get that car sideways, and then whip it right back into control on a dime, never worrying about losing it. But I also kinda love how the turbo MKIII has the power to not be so completely manageable. The MKII is notorious for rusting, much more than the MKIII. And the MKIII rear diff is also much stronger and durable.
So, I'd have to say wait for the MKIII. If your funds are limited, you can find one on the cheap needing either BHG repair, or just plenty of good easy maintainence jobs. But remember........................
You got called out by a GIRL! on the clutch job.:bigthumb: Hey Tanya!
She's our most loved MKII Goddess who could help you with ALL things MKII.