I've been running a CF one piece for years. No problems. Had it rebuilt when the thing started leaking. (yes, the front slip yoke has a pressed in cap, this cap is sealed with silicone. It was leaking gear lube out that cap, and causing a reall mess.)
So, they found that one of the u-joints was damaged when it was installed, that contributed to the failure too. (Vibration and leak eventually.)
The replacement u-joints were installed correctly, no damaged caps.
However, it appears they did not ballence the shaft as well. (I asked that they weld up the cap, so it will never leak again.)
Now over 70 it makes a nasty rumble. The driveshaft shop guys tell me they can't balance it past 2500rpm. (Truck shop.) Says mine is off less than 2 thousands...
I need to take it back to them and ask for a re-balance. (I removed it, and it's just sitting on the shelf for now, back to the two piece and quiet again for me for the past few thousand miles.)
If they can't get it perfect, I'm going to want my money back.
BTW, the CF unit is about 10 lbs.
The stocker is like 30.
IT does make a difference, but you get used to the change very quickly. (The car has plenty of power as it is, but the with CF spins the tires that much more....)